I've had the Good Karma carrot cake rice cream, and honestly I found the texture to be a little iffy (ice cream is all about texture for me). Good flavor, but it pulled out of the carton a little gelatinous for me. Double Rainbow is like in a class of its own in terms of fake ice cream, though I was really encouraged by TJ's attempt. Theirs isn't as rich and creamy as the the Double Rainbow, but the texture is right.